Long Island Bagels > Everywhere Else

A 24/7 institution that has been perfecting the bagel game for generations. Recent visitors rave about their creative tofu spreads and the fact that you can secure a hot, chewy bagel at literally any hour of the night.

Another 24-hour legendary spot, A&S is famous for their dense, old-school Jewish-style bagels. Reviewers highly recommend 'The Pauly' or 'The Greg Special' for a heavy breakfast sandwich that hits the spot after a long week.

A bustling Garden City favorite known for its incredibly fresh dough and friendly service. Locals love the everything bagels loaded with scallion cream cheese, noting the shop's consistent quality and clean, welcoming atmosphere.

Famous for their crunchy exterior and soft interior, Bagel Master is a top-tier choice for those who take their texture seriously. Reviewers emphasize the extraordinary quality of their smoked fish and the distinct, savory seasoning on their everything bagels.

Known for having a massive menu that goes far beyond just breakfast, Town Bagel is the go-to for a 'Good Morning Special.' Customers appreciate the efficient service and the variety of fresh-made salads that complement their perfectly toasted bagels.

A compact, no-frills neighborhood joint where the focus is entirely on the scratch-made dough. Fans of this spot frequently mention the 'fresh and delicious' bagels that maintain their quality even during the busiest morning rushes.